Archive for December, 2006

12-12-2006 Trading Review & Analysis

All I can say for today is that I sure am glad that it was Simulated as I hit my daily stop limit for the 3rd consecutive day. It has been 2 months since I last had such a bad string of trades. I’d like to blame it on bad luck or some external market conditions (things have been pretty slow here recently), but the truth is that I have just been making more bad trades than I typically do.

I don’t know that it is lack of patience necessarily as I was very able to wait for trades today. (Hell, I only had 5 total today) No, I think it has more to do with the impulse control in the heat of the moment brought on by indecision.

The biggest mistake I made today had to do with my exits. On the first trade of the day, I stuck around too long and watched a nice profit turn into a loss. On my second trade I didn’t stick around long enough and got scared out of a trade that would have easily taken me to my Net Daily Goal.

#3 & 5 had some good things going for them but my entry was just premature as I failed to wait for a price signal after getting a couple of converging factors going for me.

So going into tomorrow my focus will be:

1.) Wait for price confirmation before any entry
2.) Have a clearly defined exit strategy for each and every trade

Consecutive Days Hitting Net Daily Goal: 0
# Days Hitting Goal out of Last 20 (with goal of 16/20) : 0/1
Weekly PnL (Stop = -6.66) : -2.60 R-Units
Total PnL this Level (Stop = -10.00) : -2.60 R-Units

12-11-2006 Trading Review & Analysis

Today my foray in this second level of trading comes to an end as I have hit my stop loss limit of -10.00 R-Units :-(

Thus starting tomorrow I will once again be trading primarily in Simulation mode until I am once again able to hit my goal of 10 consecutive days of hitting my Net Daily Goal or 16/20. In a way it will be a good thing to once again be trading in simulation mode as it should really afford me the opportunity to hone in on exactly the kinds of mistakes that I seemed to make in live mode that I didn’t make in Sim mode.

The contrast between the two perspectives should prove to be quite illuminating and educational once I have enough data to examine. And while I am disappointed in the short term, I have tasted success before and know that I have what it takes to do so again.

That’s it for today, I need a break from the PC.

Consecutive Days Hitting Net Daily Goal: 0
# Days Hitting Goal out of Last 20 (with goal of 16/20) : 2/7
Weekly PnL (Stop = -6.66) : -3.33 R-Units
Total PnL this Level (Stop = -10.00) : -10.33R-Units

Trading Review for Week Ending 12-8-2006

This was not how I would have liked to have completed my first full week of 2nd Level Trading. I finished the week down -5.90 R-Units, brining my total since going 100% live to -7.00 R-Units. (If that total drops to -10.00 then I have to drop back down a level & earn my way back up again) I failed to hit my Net Daily Goal a single time this past week and was only profitable 3/5 days.

That’s pretty much all the bad news, now lets figure out what I was able to take away from my first full week of 100% live trading. For starters, I finally have enough data that I can perform some meaningful analysis on with my Trade Tracker Spreadsheet. So that I would have more data-points to work with, I am including all trades that I have made since November 22, which is when I went live.

What makes this week’s statistics so interesting is that I get to see first hand how I traded differently (and unsuccessfully) at Level 2, versus (successfully) at Level 1.

The first point of note is the % of 1-Factor trades that I entered. Of all the trades I entered, 15% of them had only 1 factor. This is actually a lower % than I have historically had. However, the average PnL on my 1 factor trades has nearly doubled to -.74 R-Units/trade as opposed to the historical average of -.41.

As if that change was not bad enough, the average profitability of my 3-factor trades dropped by 85% from .26 R-Unit/trade to .04. For all practical purposes, my 2-factor trades remained the same hovering around break-even.

The second number that sticks out is the 10:00-11:15 mode on my Time Distribution table. Historically speaking, this is the time-slot when I make the majority of my trades, so nothing new there. What is different is the average profitability of the trades during this time-period. The loss is 10x larger than it has ever been! It is hard to have a positive week when your most frequently occurring trade is also your least profitable. Add to that, the fact that your profitable trades are much less profitable than they have been historically and it practically becomes impossible to win.

The final point that I noticed when reviewing all of my trades is how my losses typically lump together. Often-times my worst stretches of losses are precipitated by a good trade that turns out unprofitably. Just like a poker player getting their pocket Aces cracked on the river and subsequently going on tilt, so to do I seem to react after doing everything right in a trade and still losing. At its core, this indicates to me that my trading results and my sense of self are too integrally intertwined and I am thus taking losses personally and subsequently temporarily losing my trading objectivity.

So where does all of this leave me going forward into next week?

For starters, I need to have a better plan for dealing with myself immediately following a loss. Typically, I wait until the end of the day to review all of my trades and while I will continue to do so, I think I should also implement a review of all loosing trades immediately following the closing of the position. Should this analysis reveal anything other than a “Good” trade, then a trading break no shorter than 10-minutes is to be taken. During this time, my focus will be on

A.) Calming my mind & body
B.) Internalizing the lesson of the mistake I just made (ie: visualizing similar market conditions and how I SHOULD have responded versus how I did)
C.) Visualize myself making nothing but 2 & 3-factor trades in a manner similar to ‘B’

I must also be extra-vigilant between the hours of 10:00-11:15am as to not feel compelled to force trades before the doldrums/lunch as is so often the case.

I will then focus more on patiently waiting for opportunities to take more 2tr trades as they were last week, and have been historically, my most profitable type of trade.

And finally there are the 1-factor trades. Hopefully, the above changes will decrease their frequency of occurrence. But if I do find myself in one, there are a couple things I need to change.

1.) If I am fortunate enough to notice that I am in a 1-factor trade at the time, I should close it immediately to minimize the damage as the odds are very high that it will not turn out profitably

2.) Just in general, I need to continue to be very aware of changing market conditions and not be afraid to let go of a position when they change. The doubling of the unprofitability of my 1-factor trades points to my becoming married to a position and unwilling to change direction once in a trade.

# Days at 2nd Level: 9
Consecutive Days Hitting Net Daily Goal: 0
# Days Hitting Goal out of Last 20 (with goal of 16/20) : 2/6
Weekly PnL (Stop = -6.66) : -5.90 R-Units
Total PnL this Level (Stop = -10.00) : -7.00 R-Units

12-7-2006 Daily Trading Lesson

How To Trade Using Price Divergences

It’s been a while since I’ve highlighted one of my Price Divergence plays so I wanted to go over a few details today. First a quick definition. What I call a Price Divergence is when after a comparatively strong directional rally (or decline), price then enters a correctional phase whereby the momentum indicator that you are using (In my case it is the TRIX) reverts back toward the mean while price barely budges.

Lets take today’s trade as an example. At around 11:28 this morning, the ER2 was trading around 799 and then started to rally to 801.50 (+2.50 points). During this same time, the TRIX rallied from 0 to 1.25 (+.25). For those of you more mathematically minded, you could note that this gives a ratio of (2/1).

Then price went into its corrective phase. At its lowest, price had declined -.80 points off of its most recent high, while the TRIX pulled all the way from its high of 1.25 to 0 for a ratio of (-.64/1).

So if price is moving up by 2 points when the TRIX moves up by 1 and only declining by .64 points when the TRIX moves an equal distance downwards, it points toward an obvious upwards momentum bias. Thus if & when the TRIX reverses back to the upsides, it is likely that price will move a good ways as well.

So this is what sets up the potential for a PD+ play. Then I had to wait for some convergence to corroborate the play. What I got was the following:

1.) 55-tick TRIX Double Bottom
2.) NYSE-TICK Channel breakout
3.) 2-minute + TRIX Hook
4.) 2-minute & 610-tick + Squeeze Play (When red goes to blue)

So entry was a cinch. My only mistake was in only going for a couple ticks as price continued to rally an additional couple of points after I exited with a small profit.

One important thing to note here about Price Divergences is that they are best used in the early stages of a new trend and not after an extended run. I will consider taking the first or second one after a trend change, will typically ignore the third, and start looking for fading or divergence opportunities after that point.

Hope this helps

12-7-2006 Trading Review & Analysis

Another day of good news, bad news. Again, I shot myself in the foot early in the morning (first play of the day actually) with a bad trade which I subsequently had to try to make for. That’s the bad news. The good news is that I only shot myself once and I was able to stay vigilant and patient for the rest of the day to trade & make up for loss.

After going back over my records, this pattern of early mistakes & later vindication is not new. This very same pattern occurred during my last level of trading. I remember specifically because it was almost as if there was a part of me that felt it necessary to intentionally sabotage my trading early in the day in order for me to get into the right trading mindset. (You know, because trading’s just too easy unless you start each day in a big hole to climb out of).

Before, once I was able to identify and move beyond this destructive pattern, it was the catalyst for propelling me to this level for the first time. At its root before, and I suspect now, was a tendency to over-trade in the morning session and chase after losses by loosening up on my trading standards after my first loss. Only then would I realize that I was on tilt and plan each and every trade like I should have from the beginning and slowly claw my way back into the day.

Once I eliminated the bad trades, the odds go up considerably I’d have a positive day. Unfortunately, today there was an accident not too far away that took out a power line near where I live & I was without power from 2:30 till a few minutes ago. This is unfortunate because I was in a nice little trading groove in the hours leading up to that point.

Despite being down 3 R-Units since having gone live, I feel incredibly optimistic about my future for despite the negative PnL, I haven’t been trading all that poorly.

Consecutive Days Hitting Net Daily Goal: 0
# Days Hitting Goal out of Last 20 (with goal of 16/20) : 2/5
Weekly PnL (Stop = -6.66) : -.33 R-Units
Total PnL this Level (Stop = -10.00) : -3.33R-Units